{"id":"8df63861-18cc-47d3-b670-ce44a455bcd2","type":"DATASET","name":"Study Open data Luxembourg 2021","slug":"study-open-data-luxembourg-2021","description":"A study was carried out in 2021 to identify areas for improvement within the framework of the Luxembourg Open Data project. These areas for improvement are the result of an analysis of the \"Open data maturity report 2020\" and are broken down into four areas: - actions already in place to promote - the actions to be considered - improving the implementation of the DCAT-AP standard on data.public.lu - the comparison between the functionalities offered by the udata and CKAN platforms.","free_access_class":"FREE_NO_AUTH","auth_type":"NONE","homepage_url":null,"docs_url":null,"repo_url":"https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-104021/comparatif-udata-ckan.xlsx","status":"ACTIVE","verification_state":"VERIFIED","tags":["digital"],"logo_url":"https://www.google.com/s2/favicons?sz=64&domain=download.data.public.lu","primary_source_url":"https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-104021/comparatif-udata-ckan.xlsx","extraction_confidence":"0.16","created_at":"2026-06-18T02:14:21.068Z","updated_at":"2026-10-12T20:48:50.166Z","last_verified_at":"2026-10-12T20:13:25.429Z","deprecated_at":null,"ranking_score":36,"last_ranked_at":"2026-10-10T23:55:50.107Z","last_seen_at":null,"last_validated_at":null,"last_uptime_at":"2026-10-05T06:16:36.837Z","search_vector":"'2020':43B,113B,214B,284B '2021':5A,12B,89B,176A,183B,260B 'a':177B,259B,316B 'action':51B,58B,120B,125B 'actions':222B,229B,291B,296B 'alreadi':52B,121B 'already':223B,292B 'an':206B,276B 'analysi':36B,106B 'analysis':207B,277B 'and':215B,253B,315B,325B 'ap':69B,140B,240B,311B 'are':202B,216B 'area':15B,28B,50B,100B,119B 'areas':186B,199B,221B,271B,290B 'base':103B 'based':274B 'be':231B,298B 'between':246B 'bodi':168B 'body':339B 'broken':46B,217B 'by':250B,322B,331B 'carri':9B 'carried':180B 'ckan':83B,155B,254B,326B 'comparison':74B,146B,245B,317B 'conduct':91B 'conducted':262B 'consid':61B,128B 'considered':232B,299B 'data':3A,25B,40B,96B,110B,162B,167B,174A,196B,211B,267B,281B,333B,338B 'data.public.lu':72B,143B,243B,314B 'dataset':86B,257B 'dcat':68B,139B,239B,310B 'dcat-ap':67B,138B,238B,309B 'develop':131B 'development':302B 'digit':171C 'down':218B 'for':187B,200B,272B,300B 'four':49B,118B,220B,289B 'framework':20B,191B 'function':77B,149B 'functionalities':248B,320B 'futur':130B 'future':301B 'identifi':14B,99B 'identify':185B,270B 'implement':64B,122B,135B 'implementation':235B,306B 'implemented':293B 'improv':17B,30B,62B,102B,132B 'improvement':188B,201B,273B 'improvements':303B 'improving':233B 'in':182B,224B 'into':219B,288B 'is':286B,329B 'it':285B,328B 'letzebuerg':334B 'luxembourg':4A,23B,94B,170B,175A,194B,265B,341B 'lëtzebuerg':163B 'matur':41B,111B 'maturity':212B,282B 'nation':165B 'national':336B 'of':192B,205B,208B,236B,278B,307B,318B,340B 'offer':78B,150B 'offered':249B,321B 'on':242B,275B,313B 'open':2A,24B,39B,95B,109B,161B,166B,173A,195B,210B,266B,280B,332B,337B 'organ':116B 'organized':287B 'out':181B 'place':54B,225B 'platform':84B,156B 'platforms':255B,327B 'present':87B 'presents':258B 'project':26B,97B,197B,268B 'promot':56B,124B 'promote':227B 'promoting':295B 'publish':159B 'published':330B 'report':42B,112B,213B,283B 'result':33B,204B 'standard':70B,141B,241B,312B 'studi':1A,7B,90B 'study':172A,178B,261B 'the':190B,193B,203B,209B,228B,234B,237B,244B,247B,251B,264B,279B,305B,308B,319B,323B,335B 'these':198B 'this':256B 'to':184B,226B,230B,269B,297B,304B 'udata':81B,153B,252B,324B 'was':179B 'within':18B,92B,189B,263B 'worth':123B,294B","popularity_score":"0.0000","maintenance_score":"0.5000","institution_id":null,"institution_type":null,"country_code":"LU","official_confidence":null,"proof_summary":null,"source_seed_url":null,"is_public_sector":true,"published_at":"2026-06-18T02:14:21.068Z","geographic_scope":"NATIONAL","name_en":null,"description_en":"This dataset presents a 2021 study conducted within the Luxembourg Open Data project to identify areas for improvement, based on an analysis of the Open Data Maturity Report 2020. It is organized into four areas: actions already implemented worth promoting, actions to be considered for future development, improvements to the implementation of the DCAT-AP standard on data.public.lu, and a comparison of the functionalities offered by the udata and CKAN platforms. It is published by Open Data Lëtzebuerg, the national open data body of Luxembourg.”","native_lang":"en","access_level":"direct","formats":["XLSX"],"capability_tier":"sample","trust_score":33.40384615384615,"merged_into_entry_id":null,"identity_key":"DATASET|https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-104021/comparatif-udata-ckan.xlsx|study open data luxembourg 2021","upstream_ref":null,"content_changed_at":null,"title_qualifier":null,"access":{"level":"direct","primary":{"kind":"download","label":"Download XLSX","method":"GET","url":"https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-104021/comparatif-udata-ckan.xlsx","format":"XLSX","source":"distribution","runnable":true},"actions":[{"kind":"download","label":"Download XLSX","method":"GET","url":"https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-104021/comparatif-udata-ckan.xlsx","format":"XLSX","source":"distribution","runnable":true},{"kind":"download","label":"Download data","method":"GET","url":"https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-110234/rapport-open-data-luxembourg.pdf","source":"distribution","runnable":true},{"kind":"download","label":"Download data","method":"GET","url":"https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-104048/rapport-open-data-luxembourg-dcat-ap.pdf","source":"distribution","runnable":true}],"formats":["XLSX"]},"maturity":{"entry_id":"8df63861-18cc-47d3-b670-ce44a455bcd2","granularity":"entry","granularity_label":"One unit = one catalog entry. A PROXY for the SCOPE.md §4 ladder, which governs source families, not entries: a family with 400 entries moves this reading 400 times as much as a family with one. Never compare or combine with the source_family reading.","level":"profiled","level_index":3,"level_label":"Profiled","meaning":"Schema, dimensions and licence understood","counts_as_coverage":false,"blocked_by":null,"rungs":[{"level":"discovered","level_index":1,"label":"Discovered","meaning":"Source and metadata recorded","evidence":"membership of the named population the ladder is taken over","counts_as_coverage":false,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"TRUE"},{"level":"verified","level_index":2,"label":"Verified","meaning":"Access tested successfully","evidence":"entries.verification_state = 'VERIFIED'","counts_as_coverage":false,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"entries.verification_state = 'VERIFIED'"},{"level":"profiled","level_index":3,"label":"Profiled","meaning":"Schema, dimensions and licence understood","evidence":"a data profile with at least one field (entry_data_profiles.field_count > 0)","counts_as_coverage":false,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM entry_data_profiles p WHERE p.entry_id = entries.id AND COALESCE(p.field_count, 0) > 0)"},{"level":"executable","level_index":4,"label":"Executable","meaning":"Queries run through Commodity","evidence":"entries.capability_tier = 'live' — today's proxy for \"queryable through us\"","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":false,"reached":false,"criterion":"entries.capability_tier = 'live'"},{"level":"joinable","level_index":5,"label":"Joinable","meaning":"Canonical identifiers and concepts mapped","evidence":"a field link to a canonical identifier whose sampled VALUES match its format","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":false,"reached":false,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM entry_field_links efl WHERE efl.entry_id = entries.id AND efl.identifier_id IS NOT NULL AND efl.value_status = 'match')"},{"level":"reproducible","level_index":6,"label":"Reproducible","meaning":"Snapshots and transformation evidence retained","evidence":"at least one retained evidence manifest (migration 078)","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":false,"reached":false,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM evidence_manifests em WHERE em.entry_id = entries.id)"},{"level":"guaranteed","level_index":7,"label":"Guaranteed","meaning":"Monitored against an operational reliability target","evidence":"an active reliability target with a named monitor (migration 096)","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":false,"reached":false,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM entry_reliability_targets rt WHERE rt.entry_id = entries.id AND rt.is_active = true)"}],"officialness":{"basis":"catalog_inherited","label":"Inherited from the upstream catalog: this item came from a trusted official government catalog, and that provenance — not per-item proof — is the warrant. Its own proof score is below 80 or it matched no registered institution (apps/worker/src/connectors/catalog/qualify-store.ts).","proof_confidence":null,"proven_threshold":80,"institution_id":null,"definition":"CASE WHEN COALESCE(entries.is_public_sector, false) IS NOT TRUE THEN 'not_official' WHEN COALESCE(entries.official_confidence, 0) >= 80 AND entries.institution_id IS NOT NULL THEN 'per_item_proven' ELSE 'catalog_inherited' END"},"source_family":{"key":"download.data.public.lu","label":"One unit = one source family, approximated by the serving host of the entry's primary source URL (e.g. bdl.stat.gov.pl). A COMPUTED stand-in for the curated families of SCOPE.md §5, which no table holds yet. A family sits at the highest level any of its entries has reached, because a family is integrated to the depth of its deepest working integration. Never compare or combine with the entry reading."},"generated_at":"2026-10-12T22:48:46.158Z"},"api_details":null,"dataset_details":{"id":"56da980d-41cb-44a7-b383-7d62641f257b","entry_id":"8df63861-18cc-47d3-b670-ce44a455bcd2","upstream_issued":"2023-05-16T10:39:47.840Z","upstream_modified":null,"themes":[],"update_frequency":null,"temporal_start":null,"temporal_end":null,"spatial_coverage":null,"landing_page":null,"license_id":null,"license_raw":null,"has_documentation":false,"has_data_dictionary":false,"has_versioning":false,"source_portal":null,"source_portal_url":null,"created_at":"2026-06-18T02:14:21.223Z","updated_at":"2026-10-08T13:45:06.950Z","publisher":"Open Data Lëtzebuerg","publisher_url":null,"distributions":[{"id":"4e85b370-60d6-48c0-940b-d4f09b82c989","dataset_details_id":"56da980d-41cb-44a7-b383-7d62641f257b","title":"comparative-udata-ckan.xlsx","description":null,"access_url":"https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-104021/comparatif-udata-ckan.xlsx","download_url":null,"media_type":null,"format":null,"byte_size":null,"license_id":null,"license_raw":null,"last_checked_at":"2026-10-12T20:13:24.123Z","is_available":true,"last_http_status":200,"created_at":"2026-06-18T02:14:21.569Z","updated_at":"2026-10-12T20:13:24.123Z"},{"id":"435fa53c-9960-4ca8-858f-d73584aaabf4","dataset_details_id":"56da980d-41cb-44a7-b383-7d62641f257b","title":"report-open-data-luxembourg.pdf","description":null,"access_url":"https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-110234/rapport-open-data-luxembourg.pdf","download_url":null,"media_type":null,"format":null,"byte_size":null,"license_id":null,"license_raw":null,"last_checked_at":"2026-10-04T06:44:55.722Z","is_available":true,"last_http_status":200,"created_at":"2026-06-18T02:14:21.736Z","updated_at":"2026-10-04T06:44:55.722Z"},{"id":"c34eb299-5237-498b-97bf-f7f0cd9fe965","dataset_details_id":"56da980d-41cb-44a7-b383-7d62641f257b","title":"report-open-data-luxembourg-dcat-ap.pdf","description":null,"access_url":"https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-104048/rapport-open-data-luxembourg-dcat-ap.pdf","download_url":null,"media_type":null,"format":null,"byte_size":null,"license_id":null,"license_raw":null,"last_checked_at":null,"is_available":null,"last_http_status":null,"created_at":"2026-06-18T02:14:21.888Z","updated_at":"2026-06-18T02:14:21.888Z"}],"license":null},"license":null,"reuse":{"license_id":null,"license_name":null,"license_url":null,"commercial_use":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"redistribution":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"attribution_required":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"share_alike":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"personal_data_warning":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"cache_and_mirror":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"undetermined":["commercial_use","redistribution","attribution_required","share_alike","personal_data_warning","cache_and_mirror"],"basis":"unverified","confidence":0.1,"confidence_tier":"low","source_text":null,"source_url":null,"reviewed_at":null},"license_raw":null,"latest_check":{"id":"d33b521f-5c87-43a9-ad66-9db640d09318","entry_id":"8df63861-18cc-47d3-b670-ce44a455bcd2","status":"VERIFIED","last_checked_at":"2026-10-12T20:13:25.157Z","p50_latency_ms":3668,"p95_latency_ms":null,"last_error":null,"consecutive_failures":0,"created_at":"2026-06-18T02:15:00.116Z","updated_at":"2026-10-12T20:13:25.157Z","consecutive_successes":370,"probe_url":"https://download.data.public.lu/resources/etude-open-data-luxembourg-2021/20230516-104021/comparatif-udata-ckan.xlsx","probe_method":"GET","probe_http_status":200,"probe_content_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet","probe_succeeded_at":"2026-10-12T20:13:25.157Z"},"data_profile":{"id":"dec4ee3f-88a1-42c2-b4c7-35e95a8f8f46","entry_id":"8df63861-18cc-47d3-b670-ce44a455bcd2","profile_source":"excel","profile_kind":"dataset","dataset_id":null,"fields":[{"name":"Ref","type":"text","label":null,"filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Unique reference code identifying the requirement or action item."},{"name":"As a","type":"text","label":null,"filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"User role for which the requirement or user story applies."},{"name":"I want","type":"text","label":null,"filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Description of the desired feature or improvement, as a user story."},{"name":"CKAN","type":"text","label":null,"filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Indicates whether the CKAN platform supports this feature."},{"name":"UDATA","type":"text","label":null,"filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Indicates whether the uData platform supports this feature."},{"name":"# AX","type":"int","label":null,"filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Numeric identifier or priority number for the action item."}],"field_count":6,"sample_records":[{"Ref":"AX-50","# AX":"3","As a":"portal admin","CKAN":"YES","UDATA":"YES","I want":"hightlight some datasets (with tag or other mecanism)"},{"Ref":"AX-51","# AX":"1","As a":"registered user","CKAN":"EXT.","UDATA":"CAN","I want":"to be able to ask for a new dataset that doesn't exist already"},{"Ref":"AX-53","# AX":"2","As a":"portal visitor","CKAN":"EXT.","UDATA":"CAN","I want":"to be able to see the list of all dataset request already in progress"},{"Ref":"AX-53","# AX":"1","As a":"registered user","CKAN":"NO","UDATA":"CAN","I want":"to be able to vote for a dataset request to express my interest for this specific one"},{"Ref":"AX-53","# AX":"3","As a":"portal visitor","CKAN":"NO","UDATA":"CAN","I want":"to be able to see which request are close without leading to new dataset to be added, in order to not request something that cannot be produced"}],"record_count":null,"data_size_bytes":null,"dataset_count":null,"query_examples":null,"status":"partial","error_message":null,"profiled_at":"2026-10-08T13:45:06.599Z","run_id":"2fb79f4d-60a7-4a13-a719-d29c3abd2100","created_at":"2026-07-20T11:13:40.439Z","updated_at":"2026-10-08T13:45:06.599Z","license_raw":null,"license_id":null,"consecutive_failure_count":0,"last_error_at":null,"last_error_message":null,"previewable":true,"personal_data":{"status":"none","basis":"no_person_column_cited","grain":"none","allowed":true,"columns":{"direct_identifiers":[],"family_names":[],"given_names":[],"attributes":[],"unresolved_names":[],"measures":[],"entity_identifiers":[]},"publication":null,"publication_evidence":null,"notice":"personal data: no cited column names a natural person (the cited columns are all this reads)"}},"datasets":[],"limits":[],"manifest":{"answer_sha256":"9a5af47b25362b53dddc2304876f84d9e6126b009635b731b58d982eeb761978","answer_sha256_rule":"sha256 (hex, UTF-8) of JSON.stringify(this body) after deleting the keys listed in manifest.stamped_keys from manifest, and deleting manifest itself if it is then empty. The hash was computed before the stamp existed, so no field of the stamp is inside it.","stamped_keys":["answer_sha256","answer_sha256_rule","stamped_keys","row_count","row_count_basis","live","live_basis","created_at","created_at_basis","durable_citation"],"row_count":24,"row_count_basis":"Objects that are elements of a JSON array anywhere in this body, excluding manifest. Not a claim about which collection is the answer. Largest single collection: maturity.rungs[] (7 rows).","live":true,"live_basis":"This body was produced by executing the request.","created_at":"2026-10-12T22:48:46.180Z","created_at_basis":"When this response body was assembled, deliberately OUTSIDE the hashed bytes so the same answer hashes identically on every request. Not the upstream read time — that is provenance[].retrieved_at. A zone-cached replay carries the assembly time, not your receipt time.","durable_citation":"This manifest is produced at response time and is NOT stored. A durable, replayable citation is persisted only on an explicit cite: GET /api/v1/entries/{id-or-slug}/evidence, or the MCP cite_query tool. Both are entry-scoped, because evidence_manifests is entry-shaped; a domain answer spanning several sources has no single entry and cannot be persisted through that path."}}