{"id":"a32ecce8-0023-4fd4-9481-04518b8d5094","type":"DATASET","name":"European Central Bank — Risk Assessment Indicators (RAI)","slug":"ecb-risk-assessment-indicators-rai","description":"Risk Assessment Indicators (RAI) — official time series from the European Central Bank Data Portal, published as the RAI dataflow over SDMX 2.1 REST. One endpoint serves XML (SDMX-ML), CSV (?format=csvdata) and JSON (?format=jsondata); extract exactly the series you need with a key path and startPeriod / endPeriod / lastNObservations filters. Browse and chart the same series on the ECB Data Portal.","free_access_class":"FREE_NO_AUTH","auth_type":"NONE","homepage_url":"https://data.ecb.europa.eu/data/datasets/RAI","docs_url":"https://data.ecb.europa.eu/help/api/overview","repo_url":null,"status":"ACTIVE","verification_state":"VERIFIED","tags":["economy","prices"],"logo_url":"https://data.ecb.europa.eu/themes/custom/edp/favicon.ico","primary_source_url":"https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/data/RAI/all?lastNObservations=1&format=jsondata","extraction_confidence":"0.95","created_at":"2026-07-18T21:24:13.150Z","updated_at":"2026-10-16T22:30:57.950Z","last_verified_at":"2026-10-16T22:30:57.950Z","deprecated_at":null,"ranking_score":61,"last_ranked_at":"2026-10-07T00:40:39.494Z","last_seen_at":null,"last_validated_at":null,"last_uptime_at":null,"search_vector":"'2.1':29B,99B,194B,264B 'a':217B,241B,267B,292B 'across':160B,325B 'allow':120B 'allowing':285B 'also':141B,306B 'and':206B,220B,226B,280B,299B,309B,319B 'api':101B,266B 'area':163B,328B 'as':188B,257B 'assess':5A,9B,72B 'assessment':170A,174B,237B 'bank':3A,19B,87B,168A,184B,252B 'be':307B 'brows':60B,143B 'browse':225B 'browsed':308B 'by':248B 'can':305B 'central':2A,18B,86B,167A,183B,251B 'chart':62B,145B,227B 'charted':310B 'cover':152B 'covering':317B 'csv':38B,112B,203B,277B 'csvdata':40B,114B,205B,279B 'data':20B,69B,90B,106B,150B,185B,234B,255B,271B,315B 'dataflow':26B,95B,191B,260B 'dataset':77B,242B 'ecb':68B,149B,233B,314B 'econom':153B 'economi':164C 'economic':318B 'endperiod':57B,133B,222B,298B 'endpoint':32B,104B,197B,269B 'euro':162B,327B 'european':1A,17B,85B,166A,182B,250B 'exact':46B 'exactly':211B 'extract':45B,123B,210B,288B 'filter':59B,136B 'filters':224B,301B 'format':39B,43B,113B,117B,119B,204B,208B,278B,282B 'formats':284B 'from':180B 'in':272B 'indic':6A,10B,73B,159B 'indicators':171A,175B,238B,324B 'interact':146B 'interactively':311B 'is':240B 'its':254B 'json':42B,116B,207B,281B 'jsondata':44B,118B,209B,283B 'key':53B,128B,218B,293B 'lastnobserv':58B,135B 'lastnobservations':223B,300B 'ml':37B,111B,202B,276B 'need':50B,215B 'of':243B 'offici':12B,79B 'official':177B,244B 'on':231B,312B 'one':31B,196B 'over':192B,261B 'path':54B,129B,219B,294B 'portal':21B,70B,91B,151B,186B,235B,256B,316B 'price':156B,165C,321B 'price-rel':155B 'price-related':320B 'publish':22B,82B 'published':187B,247B 'rai':7A,11B,25B,74B,94B,172A,176B,190B,239B,259B 'relat':157B 'related':322B 'rest':30B,100B,195B,265B 'risk':4A,8B,71B,158B,169A,173B,236B,323B 'same':229B,303B 'sdmx':28B,36B,98B,110B,193B,201B,263B,275B 'sdmx-ml':35B,109B,200B,274B 'seri':14B,48B,65B,81B,125B,139B 'series':179B,213B,230B,246B,290B,304B 'serv':33B,105B 'serves':198B,270B 'singl':103B 'single':268B 'specif':124B 'specific':289B 'startperiod':56B,132B,221B,297B 'the':181B,189B,212B,228B,232B,249B,258B,262B,302B,313B,326B 'through':253B 'time':13B,80B,178B,245B 'to':287B 'togeth':130B 'together':295B 'use':126B 'user':121B 'users':286B 'using':291B 'with':216B,296B 'xml':34B,108B,199B,273B 'you':214B","popularity_score":"0.0000","maintenance_score":"0.7000","institution_id":"eab3ebe3-a519-43d8-a676-4192af61f357","institution_type":"REGULATOR","country_code":"EU","official_confidence":95,"proof_summary":"Official ECB Data Portal dataflow RAI, promoted from the endpoint-verified portal entry","source_seed_url":null,"is_public_sector":true,"published_at":"2026-07-18T21:24:13.150Z","geographic_scope":"EUROPEAN","name_en":null,"description_en":"Risk Assessment Indicators (RAI) is a dataset of official time series published by the European Central Bank through its Data Portal, as the RAI dataflow over the SDMX 2.1 REST API. A single endpoint serves data in XML (SDMX-ML), CSV (?format=csvdata) and JSON (?format=jsondata) formats, allowing users to extract specific series using a key path together with startPeriod, endPeriod and lastNObservations filters. The same series can also be browsed and charted interactively on the ECB Data Portal, covering economic and price-related risk indicators across the euro area.","native_lang":"en","access_level":"direct","formats":[],"capability_tier":"live","trust_score":76.25,"merged_into_entry_id":null,"identity_key":"DATASET|https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/data/RAI/all?format=jsondata&lastNObservations=1|european central bank — risk assessment indicators (rai)","upstream_ref":null,"content_changed_at":"2026-10-14T04:18:31.678Z","title_qualifier":null,"access":{"level":"direct","primary":{"kind":"query","label":"List dataflows","method":"GET","url":"https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/dataflow/ECB","source":"query_example","runnable":true,"direct":true},"actions":[{"kind":"query","label":"List dataflows","method":"GET","url":"https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/dataflow/ECB","source":"query_example","runnable":true,"direct":true},{"kind":"query","label":"Run verified request","method":"GET","url":"https://data.ecb.europa.eu/data/datasets/RAI","source":"probe","runnable":true},{"kind":"query","label":"Dataflow structure","method":"GET","url":"https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/dataflow/ECB/RAI?references=all","source":"query_example","runnable":true,"direct":false},{"kind":"query","label":"Fetch observations (JSON)","method":"GET","url":"https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/data/RAI/all?lastNObservations=5&format=jsondata","source":"query_example","runnable":true,"direct":false},{"kind":"landing","label":"Read the docs","method":"GET","url":"https://data.ecb.europa.eu/help/api/overview","source":"docs","runnable":false},{"kind":"landing","label":"Open source record","method":"GET","url":"https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/data/RAI/all?lastNObservations=1&format=jsondata","source":"primary_source","runnable":false}],"formats":[]},"maturity":{"entry_id":"a32ecce8-0023-4fd4-9481-04518b8d5094","granularity":"entry","granularity_label":"One unit = one catalog entry. A PROXY for the SCOPE.md §4 ladder, which governs source families, not entries: a family with 400 entries moves this reading 400 times as much as a family with one. Never compare or combine with the source_family reading.","level":"executable","level_index":4,"level_label":"Executable","meaning":"Queries run through Commodity","counts_as_coverage":true,"blocked_by":null,"rungs":[{"level":"discovered","level_index":1,"label":"Discovered","meaning":"Source and metadata recorded","evidence":"membership of the named population the ladder is taken over","counts_as_coverage":false,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"TRUE"},{"level":"verified","level_index":2,"label":"Verified","meaning":"Access tested successfully","evidence":"entries.verification_state = 'VERIFIED'","counts_as_coverage":false,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"entries.verification_state = 'VERIFIED'"},{"level":"profiled","level_index":3,"label":"Profiled","meaning":"Schema, dimensions and licence understood","evidence":"a data profile with at least one field (entry_data_profiles.field_count > 0)","counts_as_coverage":false,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM entry_data_profiles p WHERE p.entry_id = entries.id AND COALESCE(p.field_count, 0) > 0)"},{"level":"executable","level_index":4,"label":"Executable","meaning":"Queries run through Commodity","evidence":"entries.capability_tier = 'live' — today's proxy for \"queryable through us\"","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"entries.capability_tier = 'live'"},{"level":"joinable","level_index":5,"label":"Joinable","meaning":"Canonical identifiers and concepts mapped","evidence":"a field link to a canonical identifier whose sampled VALUES match its format","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":false,"reached":false,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM entry_field_links efl WHERE efl.entry_id = entries.id AND efl.identifier_id IS NOT NULL AND efl.value_status = 'match')"},{"level":"reproducible","level_index":6,"label":"Reproducible","meaning":"Snapshots and transformation evidence retained","evidence":"at least one retained evidence manifest (migration 078)","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":false,"reached":false,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM evidence_manifests em WHERE em.entry_id = entries.id)"},{"level":"guaranteed","level_index":7,"label":"Guaranteed","meaning":"Monitored against an operational reliability target","evidence":"an active reliability target with a named monitor (migration 096)","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":false,"reached":false,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM entry_reliability_targets rt WHERE rt.entry_id = entries.id AND rt.is_active = true)"}],"officialness":{"basis":"per_item_proven","label":"Proven for this item: its own proof signals scored >= 80 AND it matched a registered public institution, so it would have been APPROVED on its own evidence.","proof_confidence":95,"proven_threshold":80,"institution_id":"eab3ebe3-a519-43d8-a676-4192af61f357","definition":"CASE WHEN COALESCE(entries.is_public_sector, false) IS NOT TRUE THEN 'not_official' WHEN COALESCE(entries.official_confidence, 0) >= 80 AND entries.institution_id IS NOT NULL THEN 'per_item_proven' ELSE 'catalog_inherited' END"},"source_family":{"key":"data-api.ecb.europa.eu","label":"One unit = one source family, approximated by the serving host of the entry's primary source URL (e.g. bdl.stat.gov.pl). A COMPUTED stand-in for the curated families of SCOPE.md §5, which no table holds yet. A family sits at the highest level any of its entries has reached, because a family is integrated to the depth of its deepest working integration. Never compare or combine with the entry reading."},"generated_at":"2026-10-17T07:58:03.680Z"},"api_details":null,"dataset_details":null,"license":null,"reuse":{"license_id":null,"license_name":null,"license_url":null,"commercial_use":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"redistribution":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"attribution_required":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"share_alike":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"personal_data_warning":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"cache_and_mirror":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"undetermined":["commercial_use","redistribution","attribution_required","share_alike","personal_data_warning","cache_and_mirror"],"basis":"unverified","confidence":0.1,"confidence_tier":"low","source_text":null,"source_url":null,"reviewed_at":null},"license_raw":null,"latest_check":{"id":"b9bc1c11-d787-4c0d-b019-f9fbebe67363","entry_id":"a32ecce8-0023-4fd4-9481-04518b8d5094","status":"VERIFIED","last_checked_at":"2026-10-16T22:30:57.786Z","p50_latency_ms":5021,"p95_latency_ms":null,"last_error":null,"consecutive_failures":0,"created_at":"2026-07-18T21:40:45.089Z","updated_at":"2026-10-16T22:30:57.786Z","consecutive_successes":29,"probe_url":"https://data.ecb.europa.eu/data/datasets/RAI","probe_method":"GET","probe_http_status":200,"probe_content_type":"text/html; charset=UTF-8","probe_succeeded_at":"2026-10-16T22:30:57.786Z"},"data_profile":{"id":"69d3b644-3f7f-4c83-b80c-08da3b3f6d3f","entry_id":"a32ecce8-0023-4fd4-9481-04518b8d5094","profile_source":"sdmx","profile_kind":"dataset","dataset_id":"RAI","fields":[{"name":"FREQ","role":"parameter","type":"dimension","label":"Frequency","param_in":"path","required":true,"filterable":true,"description":"2 codes (e.g. Monthly, Quarterly)","enum_values":["M","Q"],"description_en":"Frequency of the observation (e.g. monthly, quarterly)."},{"name":"REF_AREA","role":"parameter","type":"dimension","label":"Reference area","param_in":"path","required":true,"filterable":true,"description":"30 codes (e.g. Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria)","enum_values":["AT","BE","BG","CY","CZ","DE","DK","EE","ES","FI","FR","GR","HR","HU","IE","IT","LT","LU","LV","MT","NL","PL","PT","RO","SE","SI","SK","U2","D0","U3"],"description_en":"Country or reference area the data relates to."},{"name":"DD_ECON_CONCEPT","role":"parameter","type":"dimension","label":"Derived data economic concept","param_in":"path","required":true,"filterable":true,"description":"27 codes (e.g. Share of other MFIs credit to domestic general government in total assets, excluding remaining assets, Annual growth rate of MFIs new loans to households and non-financial corporations, Share of interbank loans in total loans)","enum_values":["CT1DGGV","GRNLHHNFC","IBL1TL","LC1DHHS","LEVR","LMGBLNFCH","LMGLHH","LMGLNFC","LMGOLNFCH","MMTCH","NDEPFUN","ST1TMF","SVLHHNFC","SVLHPHH","FXL1TL","LA1STL","LTD","OTHOFI1","OTHOFI4","SVLOAHH","SVLOANFC","CRED1","CREDA","ICPFA","IFOFI1","IFOFI4","IFOFIA"],"description_en":"Derived economic concept measured by the series (e.g. loan shares, growth rates)."},{"name":"CURRENCY_TRANS","role":"parameter","type":"dimension","label":"Currency of transaction","param_in":"path","required":true,"filterable":true,"description":"5 codes (e.g. All currencies combined, Euro, Euro and domestic currency)","enum_values":["Z01","EUR","U1","Z06","Z41"],"description_en":"Currency denomination of the underlying transaction."},{"name":"SOURCE_DATA","role":"parameter","type":"dimension","label":"Raw statistical data source","param_in":"path","required":true,"filterable":true,"description":"4 codes (e.g. Based on BSI data, Based on MIR data, Based on quarterly sector accounts data)","enum_values":["BSI","MIR","QSA","ICPF"],"description_en":"Underlying raw statistical dataset used to derive the value."},{"name":"DD_SUFFIX","role":"parameter","type":"dimension","label":"Derived data suffix","param_in":"path","required":true,"filterable":true,"description":"3 codes (e.g. Not applicable, Currency ratio on total currency, Euro)","enum_values":["Z","P10","E"],"description_en":"Suffix qualifying the derived data concept (e.g. currency ratio)."},{"name":"TIME_PERIOD","role":"parameter","type":"time","label":"Time period or range","param_in":"query","filterable":true,"description":"Time dimension — filter with startPeriod / endPeriod query params.","description_en":"Time period of the observation; filterable via start/end period params."},{"name":"OBS_VALUE","role":"field","type":"number","label":"Observation value","description":"The observed numeric value for each cell.","description_en":"Numeric value of the observation for this series and period."},{"name":"TIME_FORMAT","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Time format code","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Code indicating the format of the time period."},{"name":"BREAKS","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Breaks","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Indicator or note on structural breaks in the time series."},{"name":"COLLECTION","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Collection indicator","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Code describing how the data was collected or aggregated over time."},{"name":"COMPILING_ORG","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Compiling organisation","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Organisation responsible for compiling the data."},{"name":"DATA_COMP","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Underlying compilation","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Information on how the underlying data was compiled."},{"name":"DISS_ORG","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Data dissemination organisation","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Organisation responsible for disseminating the data."},{"name":"PUBL_ECB","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Source publication (ECB only)","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Reference to the ECB publication where the data appears."},{"name":"PUBL_MU","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Source publication (Euro area only)","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Reference to the euro area publication where the data appears."},{"name":"PUBL_PUBLIC","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Source publication (public)","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Reference to the public source publication for the data."},{"name":"COVERAGE","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Coverage","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Description of the scope or coverage of the data."},{"name":"DECIMALS","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Decimals","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Number of decimal places used in the observation value."},{"name":"TITLE","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Title","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Short title describing the series."},{"name":"TITLE_COMPL","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Title complement","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Additional complementary title text for the series."},{"name":"UNIT","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Unit","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Unit of measurement for the observation value."},{"name":"UNIT_MULT","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Unit multiplier","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Power-of-ten multiplier applied to the observation value."},{"name":"OBS_STATUS","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Observation status","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Status code of the observation (e.g. provisional, actual)."},{"name":"OBS_CONF","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Observation confidentiality","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Confidentiality status of the observation."},{"name":"OBS_PRE_BREAK","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Pre-break observation value","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Observation value prior to a structural break, if applicable."},{"name":"OBS_COM","role":"field","type":"attribute","label":"Observation comment","filterable":false,"description":null,"description_en":"Free-text comment attached to the observation."}],"field_count":27,"sample_records":[{"FREQ":"M","OBS_COM":null,"OBS_CONF":"F","REF_AREA":"AT","DD_SUFFIX":"Z","OBS_VALUE":5.700493393949381,"OBS_STATUS":"P","SOURCE_DATA":"BSI","TIME_PERIOD":"2026-08","OBS_PRE_BREAK":null,"CURRENCY_TRANS":"Z01","DD_ECON_CONCEPT":"CT1DGGV"},{"FREQ":"M","OBS_COM":null,"OBS_CONF":"F","REF_AREA":"AT","DD_SUFFIX":"Z","OBS_VALUE":2.566646821459284,"OBS_STATUS":"A","SOURCE_DATA":"MIR","TIME_PERIOD":"2026-08","OBS_PRE_BREAK":null,"CURRENCY_TRANS":"EUR","DD_ECON_CONCEPT":"GRNLHHNFC"},{"FREQ":"M","OBS_COM":null,"OBS_CONF":"F","REF_AREA":"AT","DD_SUFFIX":"Z","OBS_VALUE":18.736051772822016,"OBS_STATUS":"P","SOURCE_DATA":"BSI","TIME_PERIOD":"2026-08","OBS_PRE_BREAK":null,"CURRENCY_TRANS":"Z01","DD_ECON_CONCEPT":"IBL1TL"},{"FREQ":"M","OBS_COM":null,"OBS_CONF":"F","REF_AREA":"AT","DD_SUFFIX":"Z","OBS_VALUE":31.249500679076455,"OBS_STATUS":"P","SOURCE_DATA":"BSI","TIME_PERIOD":"2026-08","OBS_PRE_BREAK":null,"CURRENCY_TRANS":"Z01","DD_ECON_CONCEPT":"LC1DHHS"},{"FREQ":"M","OBS_COM":null,"OBS_CONF":"F","REF_AREA":"AT","DD_SUFFIX":"Z","OBS_VALUE":11.897513877551422,"OBS_STATUS":"P","SOURCE_DATA":"BSI","TIME_PERIOD":"2026-08","OBS_PRE_BREAK":null,"CURRENCY_TRANS":"Z01","DD_ECON_CONCEPT":"LEVR"}],"record_count":null,"data_size_bytes":null,"dataset_count":null,"query_examples":[{"url":"https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/dataflow/ECB","curl":"curl -s 'https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/dataflow/ECB' -H 'Accept: application/vnd.sdmx.structure+xml;version=2.1'","label":"List dataflows","method":"GET","description":"All dataflows (datasets) published by this agency, as SDMX-ML."},{"url":"https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/dataflow/ECB/RAI?references=all","curl":"curl -s 'https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/dataflow/ECB/RAI?references=all' -H 'Accept: application/vnd.sdmx.structure+xml;version=2.1'","label":"Dataflow structure","method":"GET","description":"Full structure of the RAI dataflow: dimensions, code lists, attributes."},{"url":"https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/data/RAI/all?lastNObservations=5&format=jsondata","curl":"curl -s 'https://data-api.ecb.europa.eu/service/data/RAI/all?lastNObservations=5&format=jsondata'","label":"Fetch observations (JSON)","method":"GET","description":"Latest observations as SDMX-JSON (the response embeds the dimension structure). Add a key like /data/RAI/D.USD.EUR.SP00.A to select a series."}],"status":"ok","error_message":null,"profiled_at":"2026-10-15T14:59:52.489Z","run_id":"b2786c0e-3d90-4fdc-a103-65c940587fc1","created_at":"2026-07-19T21:27:00.927Z","updated_at":"2026-10-15T14:59:52.489Z","license_raw":null,"license_id":null,"consecutive_failure_count":0,"last_error_at":null,"last_error_message":null,"previewable":true,"personal_data":{"status":"none","basis":"no_person_column_cited","grain":"none","allowed":true,"columns":{"direct_identifiers":[],"family_names":[],"given_names":[],"attributes":[],"unresolved_names":[],"measures":["OBS_VALUE"],"entity_identifiers":[]},"publication":null,"publication_evidence":null,"notice":"personal data: no cited column names a natural person (the cited columns are all this reads)"}},"datasets":[],"limits":[],"manifest":{"answer_sha256":"dbbca03c8a64ce5312bbd09685961ca7786b68882308e8b53338890f609b0157","answer_sha256_rule":"sha256 (hex, UTF-8) of JSON.stringify(this body) after deleting the keys listed in manifest.stamped_keys from manifest, and deleting manifest itself if it is then empty. The hash was computed before the stamp existed, so no field of the stamp is inside it.","stamped_keys":["answer_sha256","answer_sha256_rule","stamped_keys","row_count","row_count_basis","live","live_basis","created_at","created_at_basis","durable_citation"],"row_count":48,"row_count_basis":"Objects that are elements of a JSON array anywhere in this body, excluding manifest. Not a claim about which collection is the answer. Largest single collection: data_profile.fields[] (27 rows).","live":false,"live_basis":"This body was replayed from the worker edge cache (x-edge-cache: hit); the bytes, and therefore answer_sha256, are those of the execution that filled the cache.","created_at":"2026-10-17T07:58:55.033Z","created_at_basis":"When this response body was assembled, deliberately OUTSIDE the hashed bytes so the same answer hashes identically on every request. Not the upstream read time — that is provenance[].retrieved_at. A zone-cached replay carries the assembly time, not your receipt time.","durable_citation":"This manifest is produced at response time and is NOT stored. A durable, replayable citation is persisted only on an explicit cite: GET /api/v1/entries/{id-or-slug}/evidence, or the MCP cite_query tool. Both are entry-scoped, because evidence_manifests is entry-shaped; a domain answer spanning several sources has no single entry and cannot be persisted through that path."}}