{"id":"e0309c77-e472-40dc-b68b-f5316ffe1c1d","type":"API","name":"Actions Numérique Responsable","slug":"actions-numerique-responsable","description":"Pour ajouter vos actions numérique responsable à ce jeu de données, merci d'envoyer un mail à NumeriqueResponsable@grandparissud.fr","free_access_class":"FREE_NO_AUTH","auth_type":"NONE","homepage_url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/explore/dataset/actions-numerique-responsable/","docs_url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/explore/dataset/actions-numerique-responsable/","repo_url":null,"status":"ACTIVE","verification_state":"VERIFIED","tags":[],"logo_url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/assets/favicon?tstamp=153675595372","primary_source_url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/explore/dataset/actions-numerique-responsable/","extraction_confidence":"0.00","created_at":"2026-07-25T16:14:01.818Z","updated_at":"2026-09-08T20:31:06.954Z","last_verified_at":"2026-09-08T11:38:46.296Z","deprecated_at":null,"ranking_score":54,"last_ranked_at":"2026-09-04T15:32:07.218Z","last_seen_at":null,"last_validated_at":null,"last_uptime_at":"2026-09-08T20:31:06.954Z","search_vector":"'a':119B,129B,196B,207B 'action':1A,6A,10B,42B,67B 'actions':107A,112A,116B,148B,173B 'ajout':8B 'ajouter':114B 'and':147B 'are':177B 'as':195B 'at':188B 'by':182B 'ce':14B,120B 'collabor':55B 'collaboratively':161B 'comprehens':102B 'comprehensive':208B 'contact':81B,187B 'contribut':61B 'contribute':167B 'd':19B,125B 'data':32B,138B 'dataset':26B,70B,87B,132B,176B,193B 'de':16B,122B 'digit':5A,46B,66B,97B 'digital':111A,152B,172B,203B 'donnees':123B 'donné':17B 'email':77B,183B 'envoy':20B 'envoyer':126B 'franc':38B 'france':144B 'grand':35B,83B,141B,189B 'individu':58B 'individuals':164B 'initi':40B,98B 'initiatives':146B,204B 'invit':72B 'invited':178B 'is':159B 'it':158B 'jeu':15B,121B 'list':39B 'lists':145B 'mail':22B,128B 'maintain':54B 'maintained':160B 'merci':18B,124B 'national/local':91B,197B 'numerique':108A,117B 'numeriqueresponsable@grandparissud.fr':24B,130B 'numériqu':2A,11B 'of':140B,199B 'on':134B 'open':31B,137B 'open-data':30B,136B 'or':163B,210B 'organ':56B 'organizations':162B 'orient':96B 'oriented':202B 'own':169B 'pari':36B,84B 'paris':142B,190B 'portal':33B,139B 'pour':7B,113B 'practic':47B 'practices':153B 'publish':27B 'published':133B 'rather':99B,205B 'record':92B,198B 'relat':43B 'related':149B 'relev':80B 'relevant':186B 'resourc':106B 'resource':212B 'respons':3A,4A,12B,45B,65B 'responsable':109A,118B 'responsible':110A,151B,171B 'responsible-digit':64B 'responsible-digital':170B 'serv':88B 'serves':194B 'statist':103B 'statistical':209B 'submit':74B,180B 'sud':37B,85B,143B,191B 'sustain':95B 'sustainability':201B 'sustainability-ori':94B 'sustainability-oriented':200B 'technic':105B 'technical':211B 'territori':51B 'territory':157B 'than':206B 'the':135B,156B,175B,185B,192B 'their':168B 'them':181B 'this':131B 'to':150B,166B,174B,179B,184B 'un':21B,127B 'undertaken':48B,154B 'vos':9B,115B 'wish':59B 'wishing':165B 'within':49B,155B 'à':13B,23B","popularity_score":"0.0000","maintenance_score":"0.7000","institution_id":null,"institution_type":null,"country_code":"FR","official_confidence":0,"proof_summary":"Confidence: 0%","source_seed_url":null,"is_public_sector":true,"published_at":"2026-07-26T08:48:00.000Z","geographic_scope":"NATIONAL","name_en":"Responsible Digital Actions","description_en":"This dataset, published on the open-data portal of Grand Paris Sud (France), lists initiatives and actions related to responsible digital practices undertaken within the territory. It is maintained collaboratively: organizations or individuals wishing to contribute their own responsible-digital actions to the dataset are invited to submit them by email to the relevant contact at Grand Paris Sud. The dataset serves as a national/local record of sustainability-oriented digital initiatives rather than a comprehensive statistical or technical resource.","native_lang":"fr","access_level":"direct","formats":["CSV"],"capability_tier":"live","trust_score":38.75,"merged_into_entry_id":null,"identity_key":"API|https://data.grandparissud.fr/explore/dataset/actions-numerique-responsable|actions numérique responsable","upstream_ref":"data.grandparissud.fr:dataset:actions-numerique-responsable","access":{"level":"direct","primary":{"kind":"download","label":"Export CSV","method":"GET","url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable/exports/csv","format":"CSV","source":"query_example","runnable":true,"direct":true},"actions":[{"kind":"download","label":"Export CSV","method":"GET","url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable/exports/csv","format":"CSV","source":"query_example","runnable":true,"direct":true},{"kind":"query","label":"List records","method":"GET","url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable/records?limit=20","source":"query_example","runnable":true,"direct":true},{"kind":"query","label":"Select & filter","method":"GET","url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable/records?select=id%2Cquand_ou%2Cdate&where=quand_ou+is+not+null&limit=20","source":"query_example","runnable":true,"direct":true},{"kind":"query","label":"Run verified request","method":"GET","url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable","source":"probe","runnable":true},{"kind":"landing","label":"Read the docs","method":"GET","url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/explore/dataset/actions-numerique-responsable/","source":"docs","runnable":false}],"formats":["CSV"]},"maturity":{"entry_id":"e0309c77-e472-40dc-b68b-f5316ffe1c1d","granularity":"entry","granularity_label":"One unit = one catalog entry. A PROXY for the SCOPE.md §4 ladder, which governs source families, not entries: a family with 400 entries moves this reading 400 times as much as a family with one. Never compare or combine with the source_family reading.","level":"executable","level_index":4,"level_label":"Executable","meaning":"Queries run through Commodity","counts_as_coverage":true,"blocked_by":null,"rungs":[{"level":"discovered","level_index":1,"label":"Discovered","meaning":"Source and metadata recorded","evidence":"membership of the named population the ladder is taken over","counts_as_coverage":false,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"TRUE"},{"level":"verified","level_index":2,"label":"Verified","meaning":"Access tested successfully","evidence":"entries.verification_state = 'VERIFIED'","counts_as_coverage":false,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"entries.verification_state = 'VERIFIED'"},{"level":"profiled","level_index":3,"label":"Profiled","meaning":"Schema, dimensions and licence understood","evidence":"a data profile with at least one field (entry_data_profiles.field_count > 0)","counts_as_coverage":false,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM entry_data_profiles p WHERE p.entry_id = entries.id AND COALESCE(p.field_count, 0) > 0)"},{"level":"executable","level_index":4,"label":"Executable","meaning":"Queries run through Commodity","evidence":"entries.capability_tier = 'live' — today's proxy for \"queryable through us\"","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":true,"reached":true,"criterion":"entries.capability_tier = 'live'"},{"level":"joinable","level_index":5,"label":"Joinable","meaning":"Canonical identifiers and concepts mapped","evidence":"a field link to a canonical identifier whose sampled VALUES match its format","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":false,"reached":false,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM entry_field_links efl WHERE efl.entry_id = entries.id AND efl.identifier_id IS NOT NULL AND efl.value_status = 'match')"},{"level":"reproducible","level_index":6,"label":"Reproducible","meaning":"Snapshots and transformation evidence retained","evidence":"at least one retained evidence manifest (migration 078)","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":false,"reached":false,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM evidence_manifests em WHERE em.entry_id = entries.id)"},{"level":"guaranteed","level_index":7,"label":"Guaranteed","meaning":"Monitored against an operational reliability target","evidence":"an active reliability target with a named monitor (migration 096)","counts_as_coverage":true,"met":false,"reached":false,"criterion":"EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM entry_reliability_targets rt WHERE rt.entry_id = entries.id AND rt.is_active = true)"}],"officialness":{"basis":"catalog_inherited","label":"Inherited from the upstream catalog: this item came from a trusted official government catalog, and that provenance — not per-item proof — is the warrant. Its own proof score is below 80 or it matched no registered institution (apps/worker/src/connectors/catalog/qualify-store.ts).","proof_confidence":0,"proven_threshold":80,"institution_id":null,"definition":"CASE WHEN COALESCE(entries.is_public_sector, false) IS NOT TRUE THEN 'not_official' WHEN COALESCE(entries.official_confidence, 0) >= 80 AND entries.institution_id IS NOT NULL THEN 'per_item_proven' ELSE 'catalog_inherited' END"},"source_family":{"key":"data.grandparissud.fr","label":"One unit = one source family, approximated by the serving host of the entry's primary source URL (e.g. bdl.stat.gov.pl). A COMPUTED stand-in for the curated families of SCOPE.md §5, which no table holds yet. A family sits at the highest level any of its entries has reached, because a family is integrated to the depth of its deepest working integration. Never compare or combine with the entry reading."},"generated_at":"2026-09-08T21:51:33.417Z"},"api_details":{"id":"ade5131c-684d-43fa-85be-44ae9f80cffd","entry_id":"e0309c77-e472-40dc-b68b-f5316ffe1c1d","base_url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable","openapi_url":null,"graphql_url":null,"api_version":null,"spec_format":null,"endpoints_count":null,"endpoints":[],"rate_limit_info":null,"free_tier_limits":null,"ping_url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable","created_at":"2026-07-25T16:14:01.973Z","updated_at":"2026-07-25T16:14:01.973Z"},"dataset_details":{"id":"b4771906-78d1-4987-97de-894a07e13110","entry_id":"e0309c77-e472-40dc-b68b-f5316ffe1c1d","upstream_issued":null,"upstream_modified":"2026-07-06T08:25:47.000Z","themes":[],"update_frequency":null,"temporal_start":null,"temporal_end":null,"spatial_coverage":null,"landing_page":null,"license_id":null,"license_raw":null,"has_documentation":false,"has_data_dictionary":false,"has_versioning":false,"source_portal":"opendatasoft","source_portal_url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr","created_at":"2026-07-25T16:14:21.311Z","updated_at":"2026-09-02T04:11:05.990Z","publisher":null,"publisher_url":null,"distributions":[],"license":null},"license":null,"reuse":{"license_id":null,"license_name":null,"license_url":null,"commercial_use":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"redistribution":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"attribution_required":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"share_alike":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"personal_data_warning":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"cache_and_mirror":{"status":"unknown","value":null},"undetermined":["commercial_use","redistribution","attribution_required","share_alike","personal_data_warning","cache_and_mirror"],"basis":"unverified","confidence":0.1,"confidence_tier":"low","source_text":null,"source_url":null,"reviewed_at":null},"license_raw":null,"latest_check":{"id":"6af7b06a-ea4f-4cb6-aee7-b621a8477ae3","entry_id":"e0309c77-e472-40dc-b68b-f5316ffe1c1d","status":"VERIFIED","last_checked_at":"2026-09-08T11:38:46.041Z","p50_latency_ms":681,"p95_latency_ms":null,"last_error":null,"consecutive_failures":0,"created_at":"2026-07-26T12:15:18.082Z","updated_at":"2026-09-08T11:38:46.041Z","consecutive_successes":11,"probe_url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable","probe_method":"GET","probe_http_status":200,"probe_content_type":"application/json; charset=utf-8","probe_succeeded_at":"2026-09-08T11:38:46.041Z"},"data_profile":{"id":"2d256f51-9268-478a-8fbd-09d972abc776","entry_id":"e0309c77-e472-40dc-b68b-f5316ffe1c1d","profile_source":"opendatasoft","profile_kind":"dataset","dataset_id":"actions-numerique-responsable","fields":[{"name":"id","type":"int","label":null,"fill_pct":100,"filterable":true,"description":null,"description_en":"Unique identifier of the event record."},{"name":"quand_ou","type":"text","label":"Quand / Où ?","fill_pct":100,"filterable":true,"description":null,"description_en":"Free-text description of when and where the event takes place."},{"name":"date","type":"date","label":null,"fill_pct":100,"filterable":true,"description":null,"description_en":"Date on which the event takes place."},{"name":"heure","type":"text","label":null,"fill_pct":95,"filterable":true,"description":null,"description_en":"Time or time slot of the event."},{"name":"cible","type":"text","label":null,"fill_pct":95,"filterable":true,"description":null,"description_en":"Intended audience or target group of the event."},{"name":"courte_description","type":"text","label":null,"fill_pct":100,"filterable":true,"description":null,"description_en":"Short description of the event or workshop."},{"name":"structure_porteuse_de_l_evenement","type":"text","label":"Structure porteuse de l’événement","fill_pct":95,"filterable":true,"description":null,"description_en":"Organization or organizations hosting the event."},{"name":"lieux","type":"text","label":null,"fill_pct":100,"filterable":true,"description":null,"description_en":"Location or venue where the event is held."},{"name":"situation_de_l_atelier_ou_de_l_evenement","type":"text","label":"Situation de l'atelier ou de l'événement","fill_pct":95,"filterable":true,"description":null,"description_en":"Status of the workshop or event, such as a link or availability."}],"field_count":9,"sample_records":[{"id":3,"date":"2026-07-17","cible":"Pour un public scolaire puis familial","heure":"15H-18H","lieux":"Place Firmin Mercier (Cesson)","quand_ou":"Vendredi 17 juillet de 15h à 18h","courte_description":"Identique au 3 juillet","structure_porteuse_de_l_evenement":"GPS et La Citrouille","situation_de_l_atelier_ou_de_l_evenement":"https://www.grandparissud.fr/evenements/les-escapades-de-lete-7eme-edition/"},{"id":8,"date":"2026-07-28","cible":"Atelier jeune - Magicien du Numérique","heure":"matin","lieux":"Lisses","quand_ou":"Mardi 28  juillet (après-midi)","courte_description":"Atelier Orange","structure_porteuse_de_l_evenement":"GPS et Orange","situation_de_l_atelier_ou_de_l_evenement":"Complet"},{"id":10,"date":"2026-07-29","cible":"Atelier jeune - Magicien du Numérique","heure":"matin","lieux":"Evry - Micro Folie","quand_ou":"Mercredi 29 juillet (après-midi)","courte_description":"Atelier Orange","structure_porteuse_de_l_evenement":null,"situation_de_l_atelier_ou_de_l_evenement":null},{"id":14,"date":"2026-08-27","cible":"Atelier jeunes ou seniors - Selon la disponibilité de la structure","heure":"matin","lieux":"à définir","quand_ou":"Jeudi 27 aout (matin)","courte_description":"Atelier Orange","structure_porteuse_de_l_evenement":"GPS et Orange","situation_de_l_atelier_ou_de_l_evenement":"Proposition à venir"},{"id":17,"date":"2026-08-28","cible":"Magicien du Numérique ou atelier seniors","heure":"après-midi","lieux":"Corbeil-Essonnes, Maison de quartier de l'Ermitage","quand_ou":"Vendredi 28 aout (après-midi)","courte_description":"Atelier Orange","structure_porteuse_de_l_evenement":"GPS et Orange","situation_de_l_atelier_ou_de_l_evenement":"Complet"}],"record_count":"20","data_size_bytes":null,"dataset_count":null,"query_examples":[{"url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable/records?limit=20","curl":"curl -s 'https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable/records?limit=20' -H 'Accept: application/json'","label":"List records","method":"GET","description":"First 20 records of the dataset as JSON."},{"url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable/records?select=id%2Cquand_ou%2Cdate&where=quand_ou+is+not+null&limit=20","curl":"curl -s 'https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable/records?select=id%2Cquand_ou%2Cdate&where=quand_ou+is+not+null&limit=20' -H 'Accept: application/json'","label":"Select & filter","method":"GET","description":"Project specific fields (id, quand_ou, date) and filter with ODSQL where clauses."},{"url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable/exports/csv","curl":"curl -sL 'https://data.grandparissud.fr/api/explore/v2.1/catalog/datasets/actions-numerique-responsable/exports/csv' -o dataset.csv","label":"Export CSV","method":"GET","description":"Full dataset export as CSV (also available: json, parquet, xlsx)."}],"status":"ok","error_message":null,"profiled_at":"2026-09-02T04:11:05.100Z","run_id":"8a09a202-b79a-45bb-b0e0-860c3092788a","created_at":"2026-07-25T16:14:20.655Z","updated_at":"2026-09-02T04:11:05.100Z","license_raw":null,"license_id":null,"consecutive_failure_count":0,"last_error_at":null,"last_error_message":null,"previewable":true,"personal_data":{"status":"none","basis":"no_person_column_cited","grain":"none","allowed":true,"columns":{"direct_identifiers":[],"family_names":[],"given_names":[],"attributes":[],"unresolved_names":[],"measures":[],"entity_identifiers":[]},"publication":null,"publication_evidence":null,"notice":"personal data: no cited column names a natural person (the cited columns are all this reads)"}},"datasets":[],"limits":[{"id":"8c7a7302-46f3-4147-a3c8-af5a7f238952","entry_id":"e0309c77-e472-40dc-b68b-f5316ffe1c1d","limit_type":"requests_per_day","value":"5000","unit":"requests","period":"day","scope":"per-ip","source_id":null,"claim_type":"measured","confidence":"0.90","observed_at":"2026-09-02T04:11:06.164Z"}],"source_access":{"status":"accessed_despite_disallow","host":"data.grandparissud.fr","requested_path_prefix":"/api/explore/v2.1/","robots_url":"https://data.grandparissud.fr/robots.txt","user_agent_group":"*","robots_rule":"Disallow: /api/","robots_read_at":"2026-08-25T11:29:16.061Z","decision_ref":"owner decision 2026-08-22, recorded in docs/PROGRESS.md NEEDS-HUMAN: public-sector open-data portals whose purpose is machine access; the directive is an Opendatasoft vendor default reflecting no publisher intent. Concern raised and overruled; see the row.","note":"This answer is derived from a host whose robots.txt DISALLOWS the path Commodity requests, and Commodity requests it anyway under the decision named in `decision_ref`. The rule is quoted verbatim so you can read it yourself. Commodity does not send a user-agent it is not, so any `Allow` granted to a named crawler in that file is not claimed here."},"field_provenance_source_access":{"status":{"basis":"platform_computed","derived":true,"upstream_field":null,"transform":"THIS PLATFORM’S READING OF ITS OWN CONDUCT: that it requests a path this host forbids. No publisher asserts it and none was asked to","cells":{"rows":1,"delivered":1,"empty":0,"stringified":0,"truncated":0}},"host":{"basis":"platform_computed","derived":true,"upstream_field":null,"transform":"the host Commodity addressed, lowercased and stripped of scheme and port by this platform so that one host has one row and one reading","cells":{"rows":1,"delivered":1,"empty":0,"stringified":0,"truncated":0}},"requested_path_prefix":{"basis":"platform_computed","derived":true,"upstream_field":null,"transform":"THE PATH THE VERDICT IS ABOUT, derived from the base URLs this platform stores for the host — not `/`, and not an assumed `/api/`. A verdict about a path we do not call would describe someone else’s traffic","cells":{"rows":1,"delivered":1,"empty":0,"stringified":0,"truncated":0}},"robots_url":{"basis":"platform_computed","derived":true,"upstream_field":null,"transform":"where the file was fetched from — composed by this platform from the host, at the one location the protocol fixes, so it can be re-fetched and the reading disputed","cells":{"rows":1,"delivered":1,"empty":0,"stringified":0,"truncated":0}},"user_agent_group":{"basis":"stored_sample","derived":false,"upstream_field":"the `User-agent` line the deciding rule sits under","transform":"the group heading that made the rule OURS, verbatim from the stored file. Where it is `*` the directive addresses everyone; a group naming another crawler was not applied, because Commodity does not send a user-agent it is not","cells":{"rows":1,"delivered":1,"empty":0,"stringified":0,"truncated":0}},"robots_rule":{"basis":"stored_sample","derived":false,"upstream_field":"the directive line of the matching group","transform":"THE PUBLISHER’S OWN LINE, QUOTED AND UNCUT, as read from robots.txt at the moment below and stored — not fetched for this request, and not part of this response’s payload. It is here so the verdict beside it can be checked rather than taken from us","cells":{"rows":1,"delivered":1,"empty":0,"stringified":0,"truncated":0}},"robots_read_at":{"basis":"platform_computed","derived":true,"upstream_field":null,"transform":"OUR CLOCK when the file was read, never a `Date` header the origin sent. It bounds how stale this reading may be: a publisher can have changed the file since","cells":{"rows":1,"delivered":1,"empty":0,"stringified":0,"truncated":0}},"decision_ref":{"basis":"platform_computed","derived":true,"upstream_field":null,"transform":"WHO DECIDED TO CALL IT ANYWAY, AND WHEN. Recorded by this platform and required by the database before the exception may exist at all, so it can never be anonymous","cells":{"rows":1,"delivered":1,"empty":0,"stringified":0,"truncated":0}},"note":{"basis":"platform_computed","derived":true,"upstream_field":null,"transform":"this platform’s sentence explaining what the reader is holding. Written here, by us, and not a quotation of anybody","cells":{"rows":1,"delivered":1,"empty":0,"stringified":0,"truncated":0}}},"manifest":{"answer_sha256":"a565fb7ad9586bf89844cdfc7149c6db41b5d925d436867a99a28d024600ef76","answer_sha256_rule":"sha256 (hex, UTF-8) of JSON.stringify(this body) after deleting the keys listed in manifest.stamped_keys from manifest, and deleting manifest itself if it is then empty. The hash was computed before the stamp existed, so no field of the stamp is inside it.","stamped_keys":["answer_sha256","answer_sha256_rule","stamped_keys","row_count","row_count_basis","live","live_basis","created_at","created_at_basis","durable_citation"],"row_count":30,"row_count_basis":"Objects that are elements of a JSON array anywhere in this body, excluding manifest. Not a claim about which collection is the answer. Largest single collection: data_profile.fields[] (9 rows).","live":false,"live_basis":"This body was replayed from the worker edge cache (x-edge-cache: hit); the bytes, and therefore answer_sha256, are those of the execution that filled the cache.","created_at":"2026-09-08T21:51:53.301Z","created_at_basis":"When this response body was assembled, deliberately OUTSIDE the hashed bytes so the same answer hashes identically on every request. Not the upstream read time — that is provenance[].retrieved_at. A zone-cached replay carries the assembly time, not your receipt time.","durable_citation":"This manifest is produced at response time and is NOT stored. A durable, replayable citation is persisted only on an explicit cite: GET /api/v1/entries/{id-or-slug}/evidence, or the MCP cite_query tool. Both are entry-scoped, because evidence_manifests is entry-shaped; a domain answer spanning several sources has no single entry and cannot be persisted through that path."}}